Curry Castle, Johnstown
Ribbon Awarded: Blue Ribbon
Curry Castle opened with a soft launch, and a new restaurant deserves a little runway before anyone hangs a ribbon on it. So my wife and I gave it three tries before writing a word: once as carryout, once through DoorDash, and once in the dining room after it opened to sit-down guests.
The Front Door
If you stop in right now, odds are you’ll be greeted by Tintu, who runs the front of the house. He’s polite and easy to talk to. He asked whether we were familiar with Indian food, offered to walk us through the menu, took our order, and told us how long it would take. There isn’t much in the lot around the building, so we walked one lap and came back. The food was ready a moment later.
The DoorDash order showed up in about the same window as anything else we order from the West Hills side of town. Dine-in followed the same routine, with Tintu and a second gentleman handling the tables. On all three visits the place was clean from front to back, and the staff was friendly and polite each time.
The Table
If you know Indian food, you’ll find this menu on point. I haven’t found a weak spot yet. Here’s what we’ve worked through so far:
- Vegetable Samosa. Crisp fried pastry folded around spiced potato and peas. Some version of this little triangle turns up at street stalls from Central Asia clear down into Southeast Asia, and this one holds its own.
- Vegetable Pakora. Vegetables dragged through chickpea-flour batter and fried. It’s the snack you’d want on a rainy afternoon with a cup of chai.
- Saag Paneer. Spinach cooked down slow with garlic and ginger and wrapped around cubes of paneer, a fresh white cheese that softens in the pan and keeps its shape.
- Chicken Amwala. Chicken in a creamy mango sauce with ginger and warm spices. It’s gently sweet, with a little chili hanging back behind the fruit.
- Chicken Jalfrezi. Chicken seared hot with onion, bell pepper, tomato and sliced green chili. It eats closer to a stir-fry than a stew, chunky and bright.
- Lamb Tikka Masala. The familiar tomato-and-cream sauce, with lamb braised long enough that it gives way under a fork.
- Saag Lamb. Lamb braised in spinach with garlic and ginger until it pulls apart. Dark green, earthy, and a good choice for a cold night in Johnstown.
- Chicken Korma. Chicken in a pale sauce of ground cashew, yogurt and cream with green cardamom. It’s the mildest curry in the house and a good way to start somebody new to Indian food.
- Garlic Naan. Flatbread slapped against the wall of the clay oven and brushed with butter and garlic. You’ll want it for mopping up sauce.
- Rosemary Naan. The same bread with a Mediterranean herb on it. It isn’t traditional, and it works.
- Peshawari Naan. A sweet naan stuffed with coconut, nuts and raisins, named for Peshawar up near the Khyber Pass. Tear off a piece between bites of something hot.
- Gulab Jamun. Soft balls of milk dough, fried and soaked in syrup scented with rose and cardamom. “Gulab” means rose, and you can taste it.
- Mango Lassi. Yogurt blended with ripe mango, thick and cold. It also puts out the fire if you went too high on the spice scale.
Portions run a touch lighter than we’re used to at Indian restaurants. What lands on the plate makes up for it: rich, flavorful, first-rate cooking. I like my pakora bulkier, but that’s my own taste, and theirs sits well within what you’d expect from the dish. Across three visits, we didn’t leave a bite we were unhappy with.
The Heat
Curry Castle uses a 1-to-4 spice scale, and we tried our way up it. Levels 1 and 2 are safe for pretty much anyone. Level 3 is a good pick for folks used to “white people seasoning” who still want a meal with some kick. Level 4 is for people who truly love hot food. They mean it.
Help Wanted
They’re hiring for the kitchen, and especially for weekend serving. If you know someone looking for work, send them over. And if you eat there, sing their praises.